Food manufacturing facilities which use alcohol or other high-VOC containing sanitizers may be impacted by a series of new rule amendments proposed by the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District (SJVAPCD). SJVAPCD has proposed to amend Rule 4663 – Organic Solvent Cleaning, Storage, and Disposal to include ozone contingency measures for food manufacturing facilities which will reduce volatile organic compound (VOC) emissions from the use of organic solvents, i.e. alcohol-based sanitizers. These contingency measures are intended to satisfy Federal Clean Air Act (CAA) planning requirements. If approved, the restrictions would only take effect if the San Joaquin Valley air basin fails to meet required ozone attainment goals or other CAA obligations. Still, it is important to participate in these rulemaking processes, as agencies are very reluctant to amend a rule once it has been put in place and approved by California Air Resources Board and the US Environmental Protection Agency.
Under the current interpretation of Rule 4663 (9/20/2007) food manufacturing facilities are not typically affected, and therefore no standard applies for the use of sanitizers in these applications. However, in 2024 SJVAPCD first proposed to amend Rule 4663, as result of EPA issuance of the final contingency measure guide, which would require food manufacturing facilities to meet a 200 g/L VOC limit on all organic solvents which are used for sanitizing processing equipment.
At the time of the initial proposal, the District claimed that compliant products were available and used that finding to take the position that no reformulation/development would be required and that no source-specific exemptions would be necessary. However, this was based on a false perception that sanitizers and their use cases are all generic and interchangeable, which is far from the industry reality that these are used on a case-by-case basis and highly tailored to each use case. Trinity made the District aware of the degree of specialization and the importance of having access to alcohol-based sanitizers where food safety makes them necessary.
In particular, food-contact surfaces for ready to eat foods often require isopropyl alcohol sanitizers because it has the broadest-spectrum efficacy in killing microbes and its fast drying. These are significant because the alternatives may not kill a specific microbial strain that the plant is struggling to control, because surfaces left wet tend to rapidly recolonize and reinfect again, and because FDA requires rinsing of any food contact surface with over 200 ppm of quaternary ammonium compounds (quat), which are a lower-emitting class of sanitizers. Overall, then, while there are typically applications in every food plant for which quat may be appropriate, there are also applications in many food plants where quat is not appropriate, and only alcohol is fully suitable for ensuring that the final product is safe for human consumption.
Rule Package Undergoes Further Review
SJVAPCD recognized these concerns and the rule package was tabled for further research until September 2026, at which point a presentation indicated a continued intent to draft a rule with a 200 g/L VOC limit is proposed. However, the presentation indicated a new intent to includes an exemption for “low moisture food operations”, apparently based on inspiration from Sacramento Metro AQMD’s Rule 466. Rule 466 includes an exemption from its 200 g/L sanitizer VOC limit for “low moisture food operations”, which are defined as “A food with a water activity less than 0.85 or other applicable standards approved by the Air Pollution Control Officer, California Air Resources Board, and U.S. Environmental Protection Agency”. This “water activity” is a Food and Drug Administration defined term, but a 0.85 cutoff is not adequate to exempt foods such as bread and tortillas from being wetted by contact with surfaces sanitized with a water-based sanitizer. This exemption concept is a good first step to ensure that food manufacturers and processors have the food safety tools they need. However, the precedent established by the Sacramento Metro rule lacks any other flexibility or discretionary authority to approve alternatives.
Consequentially, this could impact manufacturing of ready to eat and frozen foods where the product may not meet the definition of “low moisture food operations” and thus limits sanitizer options in a way that may interfere with the ability of Valley food plants to produce saleable products- as in this industry, only safe products are saleable. Wes Younger, manager of Trinity’s Bakersfield office, has national experience with permitting and compliance of the use of food plant cleaning and sanitizing chemicals for a variety of food process industries and is encouraging additional flexibility options to be included in the Proposed Rule. These could be based on the general architecture of many South Coast AQMD VOC control rules, which often specify that the rule limits only apply when a facility or process has aggregate emissions over 833 pounds per month, or allow up to a specified amount of noncompliant solvent to be used each month. Such strategies could be used to give food plant processors more flexibility to use alcohol-based sanitizers when and where they are absolutely needed, but also ensure that sanitizer emissions are generally minimized through the use of lower-emitting products where they are suitable.
Community Feedback Impacts Regulations
Public participation can significantly influence District rulemaking processes. District staff develop rules based on the information available to them, but they are not experts on every individual field they are charged with regulating, and they cannot anticipate all of the edge cases and trouble spots that may arise from a given rule concept. When the regulated community reaches out to the rulemaking staff and/or provides public comments, regulations can be better tailored to the specific needs of an industry such that the underlying environmental goals are satisfied but exemptions or alternatives provided for the specific circumstances that merit them. Trinity encourages the regulated community participate in this rulemaking process to contact Kyle Matsumura at 559.230.6000 immediately to discuss the specific needs and concerns for their facility in the development of a rule to restrict the VOC content of sanitizers. The community can also submit formal written comments once the public comment period opens (within 30 days following issuance of a draft rule).
SJVAPCD has indicated to Trinity that the proposed rule language will be posted on the District Website by November 16. Although it is largely unknown until that date what flexibility the Proposed Rule will include, the public workshops have illustrated some oversight of industry norms which may contribute to impracticality for many operations.
Furthermore, the District is likely draw inspiration from related precedent rules, such as SMAQMD Rule 466, as is common practice among California air Districts. Trinity strongly suggests that all facilities in this sector review the rule language and provide rulemaking input and public comments explaining their concerns and needs so that the resulting rule can be as practical as possible. Without strong public participation from the publication of the Proposed Rule in November 2026 through there is a strong likelihood that the Proposed Rule will be approved by the District’s Governing Board at the December 16 Public Hearing without further discussion or revisions.
Trinity Can Support Your Involvement
Interested parties should also plan to participate in the Public Hearing to ensure that the eventual Final Rule considers the practical and technical considerations important to the continued operation of the Valley’s food and agricultural processors. Trinity can arrange for District meetings, assist with evaluation of the Proposed Rule and the preparation of public comments to maximize the regulated community’s ability to influence the rulemaking process. For more information on Rule 4663 revisions please reach out to Wes Younger at 661.282.2200 x1962.